Record-breaking 976 entries in British Pie Awards

Judges from across the world, including the US and Japan, will cast their expert eyes over 23 different classes.

09 March 2022

Judges at the world-famous British Pie Awards have their work cut out this year with a record-breaking 976 entries, including one made with kangaroo meat.

Returning to its traditional March timing after the Covid pandemic saw last year’s competition moved to September, 151 judges were running an expert eye over 23 different classes of hot and cold savoury and dessert pies and pasties.

The highly competitive contest, which plays out over three days, is again taking place at St Mary’s Church in the home of the pork pie, Melton Mowbray in Leicestershire.

The Melton Mowbray British Pie Awards 2022
The competition takes place at St Mary’s Church in Melton Mowbray (Jacob King/PA)

The ceremonial blessing of the pies in what organisers have called “the cathedral of pies” was delivered this year by the Bishop of Leicester, Martyn Snow.

His words also remembered those in the world at the moment who are without food, with special reference to those in Ukraine.

The judges – including one from Sonoma in Californian wine country and another from Japan – first gathered on the wooden seats of the choir in the chancel, where chairman of judges Colin Woodhead told them: “When you’re marking, please keep it moving along.

“We’ve got, is it 976 pies?

“If not, we’ll be here until midnight,” he said, before adding: “Just enjoy yourselves.”

Pie judging
The competition sees pairs of judges assess entries against a series of criteria (Jacob King/PA)

The judges, many of whom are experts and old hands, are asked to mark the pies on various criteria including eating qualities, the filling, and how a maker could improve their entry.

Mr Woodhead, who has been judging chairman for four years, said: “What we’re trying to do is improve overall qualities of pies in the United Kingdom – it’s all about improvement.”

The competition has been growing in popularity and profile, since launching in 2009, with this year’s farthest pie-maker coming from Lochinver – more than nine hours’ drive away from Melton.

Another first-time entrant, Murray Lauchlan, a seventh-generation butcher, of David Comrie & Son in Comrie, Perthshire, travelled more than six hours to “come and see what it’s all about”.

Murray Lauchlan
Murray Lauchlan, a first-time entrant, travelled from Perthshire (Richard Vernalls/PA)

The family firm has put in six entries this year, including two pies featuring their award-winning black pudding and haggis.

Describing the atmosphere as “amazing”, Mr Lauchlan said he was pleasantly “surprised” at the sheer number of entries, though he said that, since Covid, pies have generally become more popular.

“For independent businesses like us, people weren’t going to the supermarket, they were coming to us, and that has carried on,” he said.

He added: “They’re realising the benefit of buying fresh produce, and the British Pie Awards highlight what local independent delis, butchers and bakers are doing.”

The Melton Mowbray British Pie Awards 2022
Pies are judged on a number of criteria (Jacob King/PA)

The award’s most eye-catching entry on paper is a kangaroo, ale and Tasmanian pepper-berry pie.

But other varieties include spiced miso beef short ribs and sour cherry; a crab, potato and chives pasty; a Christmas dinner pie – complete with turkey, stuffing and all the trimmings; and a creamy cashew, pea and mushroom pie.

Judges hard at work
Some of the record-breaking number of entries (Jacob King/PA)

Categories range from vegan – which produced the overall winner in 2019 – and free-from, to the traditional pork pie, with the supreme champion due to be announced on Friday.

Matthew O’Callaghan, chairman of the Melton Mowbray Pork Pie Association and host of the British Pie Awards, said: “Fortunately we have survived Covid very well indeed.

“In fact pie-makers, sponsors and judges have come back with a bang – this is a record (number of entries) for the British Pie Awards.”

Mr O’Callaghan added that he believes pies are the UK’s “contribution to international cuisine.”

More from Perspective

Get a free copy of our print edition


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed

Your email address will not be published. The views expressed in the comments below are not those of Perspective. We encourage healthy debate, but racist, misogynistic, homophobic and other types of hateful comments will not be published.