A spectre is haunting Europe and this time it’s not just Peter Mandelson in a sheet going “Woooo!” It’s the eerily still-animated corpse of capitalism that lies belching poisons into our rivers and streams, struggling to raise its head to gobble up more of our public realm while making it worse in every conceivable way.
I’m always amused by the hopefulness of people who use the phrase “late-stage capitalism” because it implies a stage after capitalism that isn’t just “having consumed the entire planet, we all die”. I spent a couple of years producing a podcast in which a tech CEO, with a background in natural science, interviewed thinkers and historians about what we could learn from the past and what it implied for our future. Amidst their tales of why we shouldn’t try to reinstate trial by combat (messy and now subject to lawsuits), of who controlled the creation of histories (monks), and who owned the most colourful brothels in medieval Prague (also monks), we spoke to scientists.
Here’s the thing: whatever discipline the natural scientists we spoke to worked in, the message was much the same: everything is fucked. We’re running out of soil, we’re running out of pollinators, we’re running out of temperate rainforests, we’re running out of fish. The trees are moving north, our rivers are clogged with industrial waste, the oceanic currents are getting smaller, and we have created a new age of fires so extreme that they will be the way the future remembers us, like Boudicca’s Colchester: a line of particularly interesting ash in an otherwise unremarkable rock formation.
In whatever discipline, in whatever field, that’s the news from the past few years. The one exception was Mo Gawdat, the ex-chief business officer at Google X, who was relatively cheery about the potential of AI, and how we could use it to improve our lives. Since that interview, he’s changed his mind and is now telling everyone to stop having children until we get the AI situation figured out.
No one ever made money by not selling poisons
In all of these cases, however, there seemed to be reasonably feasible solutions to the immediate problems. We could ban neonicotinoid pesticides, champion regenerative agriculture, rewild more of our public lands, move to pasture-grazing rather than grain-feeding livestock, reduce antibiotics in the food chain, restore wetlands, plant more trees, make our waterways rights of way, have controlled burns of woodlands, and establish public rights to the waters around our coastline. The changes needed, on the whole, seemed trivially small; the work of one parliament with ample time for MPs to develop sidelines promoting second businesses, sliding through dodgy planning proposals, or finding new mistresses.
The reason none of those changes was ever going to happen, of course, was that it was very difficult to make money at any of them. They were measures of good stewardship, rather than a lucrative opportunity for a consortium of Tory donors to make a quick couple of million sticking new trees in scrubland. No one ever made money by NOT selling poisons. True, rewilding has a few high Tory proponents – members of the wellies and eugenics brigade, who worry not that we’ve got too many people but too many of the “wrong sort” of people. Wealthy country folk who will sell you a pasture-fed bison steak from their ancestral estate, but would rather you didn’t seek the right to roam through their wildflower meadows.
The single thing that could help to solve all these problems is, of course, the one that’s least likely to happen: immediate reduction of carbon emissions. It’s the one that the bloated carcass of capitalism makes most impossible.
The media liked to say that Sunak “watered down” the Tory party’s commitments to net zero. This makes it sounds like it’s lemon squash rather than the measures necessary for us to continue life as we know it on planet Earth. I didn’t have my dog put to sleep, I watered down my commitment to its future welfare. It’s not a divorce, it’s a watering down of upcoming anniversary presents. Dignitas is simply watering down its patients’ hopes of future Swiss holidays.
Yes, capitalism is a ghoul that has killed itself and killed us and is still immovably wedged on top of the Houses of Parliament: its translucent grey, greasy buttocks, moulded to the shape of the roof of St Stephen’s Hall. The two knights of the realm in charge of the other two parties won’t challenge it.
The politicians in charge at the moment cling to it, try to resuscitate it with handouts of public money to their friends’ businesses, sing its praises as it wheezes its last breath behind them. Yes, a spectre haunts us, and we can only hope that it haunts us for some time to come. Because when it goes, it takes us all with it.
Nathaniel Tapley is a comedy writer and performer on the TV shows you hate




