An Olympic Games in Paris, a British general election with a major party haemorrhaging seats, and a US election with an uninspiring incumbent president seeking four more years. Welcome to, er, 1924, a deliciously exact 100-year timeslip.
One of history’s most fascinating aspects is the extent to which it repeats or rhymes, and what lessons, if any, it offers up in doing so. Last century’s Twenties are, of course, not complete without the prefix “roaring”. It’s a seductive idea, that great communal suffering is replaced by explosions of hedonistic decadence and intellectual endeavour – from the worst of times to the best, because the human spirit can be suppressed but never extinguished – and it goes back much further than the diptych of the Great War and the 1920s. Think of Oliver Cromwell’s joyless Protectorate giving way to a wild and licentious 1660s Restoration full of great leaps forward in art and science, or of the Renaissance as an equal and opposite reaction to the crisis of the late Middle Ages.
The French, as always the go-to guys for the bon mot, refer to the 1920s as les années folles, the mad years. In 1920 John F Carter Jr, a recent Yale graduate who would go on to be friends with both Franklin Roosevelt and Harry Truman, penned an essay in Atlantic Monthly called “These Wild Young People”. “The older generation had certainly pretty well ruined this world before passing it on to us,” he wrote. “They give us this thing, knocked to pieces, leaky, red hot, threatening to blow up; and then they are surprised that we don’t accept it with the same attitude of pretty, decorous enthusiasm with which they received it… We have been forced to live in an atmosphere of ‘tomorrow we die’ and so, naturally, we drank and were merry.”
Small wonder that F Scott Fitzgerald, the Roaring Twenties’ pre-eminent chronicler, called the decade “the most expensive orgy in history”. Gatsby and jazz, Art Deco and the Charleston, movies and Model Ts: these are the images that spring to mind almost unbidden, so deep and enduring are they as cultural touchstones. America today is still underpinned by the overarching spirit of that age: materialism, consumption, the primacy of satisfying individual needs. A fridge in the house, a car on the drive and trips to the cinema were rarefied treats at the start of the decade, but by the time it ended they were practically birthrights for many Americans.
With movies in particular (and their bedfellow, radio programmes), the Twenties also saw the start of American cultural hegemony in the West. The American experience of the Roaring Twenties is therefore instinctive and definitive, but it’s by no means the only one. Britain shared some of this: for Fitzgerald in New York read Noël Coward in London, whose mid-decade purple patch saw four of his shows (The Vortex, Fallen Angels, Hay Fever and On with the Dance) running simultaneously in the West End, all of them scandalous, humorous or both. Bright Young Things such as Cecil Beaton, Nancy Mitford and Elizabeth Ponsonby threw lavish parties, fascinating and repelling the public in equal measure. And both Henry Segrave and Malcolm Campbell flew the Union Jack on Florida’s Daytona Beach by breaking the land speed record, an intoxicating combination of danger, daring and skill.
In other respects the British experience was much less extreme. Winston Churchill’s 1925 decision to restore the gold standard, drastically overvaluing the sterling exchange rate and hammering the balance of payments, was the central plank of a cautious monetary policy. The domestic stock market didn’t climb as vertiginously as the Dow Jones, which quintupled in value over the decade: nor was consumer credit nearly as widely available in Britain as it was in America.
If the icons of the Twenties were largely American, so too were those of the Thirties: bread lines, soup kitchens, the Dust Bowl, John Steinbeck, and Florence Owens Thompson. To an extent this was the spectacular bust which followed an equally spectacular boom, but it was also a reflection that the Twenties had, to say the least, not roared for everyone.
For a small section of society, largely white and wealthy, the Twenties really
For a small section of society, largely white and wealthy, the Twenties really had been how they are traditionally portrayed
With movies in particular (and their bedfellow, radio programmes), the Twenties also saw the start of American cultural hegemony in the West. The American experience of the Roaring Twenties is therefore instinctive and definitive, but it’s by no means the only one. Britain shared some of this: for Fitzgerald in New York read Noël Coward in London, whose mid-decade purple patch saw four of his shows (The Vortex, Fallen Angels, Hay Fever and On with the Dance) running simultaneously in the West End, all of them scandalous, humorous or both. Bright Young Things such as Cecil Beaton, Nancy Mitford and Elizabeth Ponsonby threw lavish parties, fascinating and repelling the public in equal measure. And both Henry Segrave and Malcolm Campbell flew the Union Jack on Florida’s Daytona Beach by breaking the land speed record, an intoxicating combination of danger, daring and skill.
In other respects the British experience was much less extreme. Winston Churchill’s 1925 decision to restore the gold standard, drastically overvaluing the sterling exchange rate and hammering the balance of payments, was the central plank of a cautious monetary policy. The domestic stock market didn’t climb as vertiginously as the Dow Jones, which quintupled in value over the decade: nor was consumer credit nearly as widely available in Britain as it was in America.
If the icons of the Twenties were largely American, so too were those of the Thirties: bread lines, soup kitchens, the Dust Bowl, John Steinbeck, and Florence Owens Thompson. To an extent this was the spectacular bust which followed an equally spectacular boom, but it was also a reflection that the Twenties had, to say the least, not roared for everyone.
For a small section of society, largely white and wealthy, the Twenties really had been how they are traditionally portrayed.
But that portrayal, of course, came from the fact that it was exactly that same section of society that had access to and control of popular narratives. By contrast, there wasn’t much to roar about if you were an African-American seeking employment in, say, Baltimore, or a British worker taking part in the 1926 General Strike (nor, of course, a combatant in the Russian civil war, or a victim of hyperinflation in Weimar Germany). Since 1855, unemployment in Britain has only ever twice been higher than it was in the 1920s: during the Great Depression which followed, and then again in the 1980s. The Twenties also saw the first Labour prime minister, Ramsay MacDonald in 1924, and the coalescing idea of two nations in one: a prosperous and consumerist south set against a hardscrabble industrial north.
To what extent, therefore, might the 2020s roar as much as their predecessor? There are certainly parallels. We have emerged from a global shock in the shape of the covid pandemic, and the 1920s consumer revolution prompted by mass assembly production lines is echoed in today’s tech maelstrom, though whether this will have a similar effect on mass-scale productivity and manufacturing remains unknowable.
But the parallels are also negative, and arguably the most striking of all is wealth inequality. At the start of the 1920s, America’s richest one per cent owned 36 per cent of the nation’s wealth; by the eve of the Wall Street Crash, that figure was 48 per cent. Today it is still around 33 per cent, and the steepest increase in billionaires’ wealth on record occurred during covid. In the UK, the richest ten per cent of households account for 43 per cent of all wealth, with the poorest 50 per cent holding just nine per cent. And for all the current talk of levelling up, the north-south divide in the UK remains as stark and bitter as ever. Neither fundamental economic laws nor the basic tenets of human nature have changed in those 100 years.
Unintended faultlines are often in place, even though not always visible at the time. What will be our equivalent of the lack of stock market regulation which both propelled the Roaring Twenties and helped cause the crash that ended them? How will we echo the punitive reparations imposed on Germany at the Treaty of Versailles which were designed to keep the country docile and manageable, but which eventually helped create the conditions for Adolf Hitler to seize power and start another world war?
It was that war which gave us another example of how we prefer simple and uplifting narratives to more complex and problematic hard truths. The Blitz spirit is usually meant to signify a stoic, brave population looking out first and foremost for each other, but as with the Roaring Twenties this is only partially accurate. Crime rates went up more than 50 per cent during WWII, with looting rife and a thriving black market; people were often panicked, scared and distrustful, and sometimes had to be forced into underground shelters; the five words most closely associated with the Blitz spirit than any others – “keep calm and carry on” – were rarely used at the time. More than two million posters were printed but vanishingly few of them were displayed, and it wasn’t until more than 50 years later that a bookshop owner in the Northumberland town of Alnwick found one and reintroduced it to an enthusiastic public.
A similar dichotomy between light and dark can be found when looking at the Paris Olympics of 1924 and 2024. Certainly, there was much to like and value in Paris 1924. They were the sixth Games of the modern era and the last over which the founder Baron Pierre de Coubertin presided, but in many ways they were the first Games to really begin encapsulating what we think of as the Olympic spirit. They were the first Games to use the Olympic motto Citius, Altius, Fortius (Faster, Higher, Stronger).
They were the first Games with any real global reach: 44 countries participated and more than 1,000 journalists were on site. They were the first Games to introduce the now iconic closing ceremony ritual where the flags of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and both the outgoing and incoming host nations are raised to symbolise the movement’s continuity. They were the first Games to cross over into other aspects of the entertainment culture: American swimmer Johnny Weissmuller, who won three golds, went on to play Tarzan in a dozen Hollywood films, and the exploits of the British sprinters Harold Abrahams and Eric Liddell were later immortalised in 1981’s Chariots of Fire.
They were the first Games to have a black individual gold medallist in American long jumper William Hubbard, an achievement of whose import he was well aware even before he had done it: in a letter sent on the cusp of setting sail for Europe, he wrote “I’m going to do my best to be the FIRST COLORED OLYMPIC CHAMPION”, with the word “colored” underlined twice. And they were the first Games in which female competitors, though still a tiny minority (less than five per cent of the 3,000 athletes taking part), made headlines. American backstroker Sybil Bauer was so quick that there were calls for her to take on the men: Helen Wills won two tennis golds and eventually achieved international fame with 31 Grand Slam titles. A century on, Paris 2024 will for the first time have equal numbers of male and female athletes competing. (London 2012 was the first time that every participating nation had at least one female athlete in its team.)
Not that Paris 1924 was above criticism of course. “Olympic Games doomed” shrieked a Times headline of the day, and beneath it ran an excoriation of various controversies in the boxing and rugby competitions. “It has once more been demonstrated with dreadful clearness that the Games exacerbate international bitternesses… the ideal which inspired the rebirth of the Games was a high one – namely by friendly rivalry and sport to bind together the youth of all nations in a brotherhood so close and long that it would form a bulwark against the outbreak of all international animosities… [but] the world is not yet ripe for such a brotherhood…. [and] the peace of the world is too precious to justify any risk of its being sacrificed on the altar of international sport.”
The Times declared a “funeral oration” for the entire Olympic movement, and though at this distance that seems not merely erroneous but actively overblown, the Games’ continued existence is not assured even now. Hosting the Olympics was once seen as desirable, even borderline imperative: nine cities initially bid for the 2012 Games won by London, five went through to the final round, and the competition between London and its two closest rivals, Paris and Madrid, was fierce.
Now fewer and fewer cities want to host the Games. Budapest, Boston, Rome and Hamburg all pulled out of the 2024 iteration at various stages of the process. Costs run into tens of billions of dollars, dwarfing any economic benefits for the host city. Residents are displaced under eminent domain rulings to allow the construction of facilities that often end up as white elephants, making a mockery of sustainability and legacy pledges. Temporary restrictive measures brought in to ensure security can easily become permanent. And the opportunities for corruption at every stage are legion.
All these factors are likely to skew the pitch for future Games towards cities in non-democratic countries, where leaders have to worry less about inconveniences such as public opinion, legal rights and financial accountability. The drive to bring the Games to all corners of the world is laudable, but the reality soon runs up against unlovely regimes using the Games for egregious sportswashing and dubious international influence. Just as the Roaring Twenties only roared for a few, so too must the Olympic motto seem absurd and irrelevant to the many who gain no benefit from the Games, even – especially – when they are being held in their home cities.
“The Olympics are unreformable,” says author David Goldblatt, “and I think on balance they do more harm than good”
The solution is unclear. A permanent home for the Games has been mooted, or perhaps a small number of host cities which rotate the honour between them. But the travelling circus aspect of the Olympics is its USP, and this suits the IOC down to the ground: they pitch camp in a new city, oblige that city to spend heavily, keep most of the profits themselves, skip town the moment the show’s over, and let someone else deal with all the problems that are left behind.
“The Olympics are unreformable,” says author David Goldblatt, “and I think on balance they do more harm than good. We’re in for a very, very, very rough and turbulent couple of decades in terms of global change. What’s the Olympics going to look like in the face of that? It already looks like an absurdity to me. And I wonder what a generation 30 years younger than me will be thinking while the world’s on fire.”
But in the Olympics we can also see writ large much of what makes sport so appealing: beauty, belonging, camaraderie, excellence, hope, respect, ritual, theatre. The Games are a chance for the youth of the world to break bread with each other – “a quadrennial celebration of the springtime of humanity”, as de Coubertin put it – and no matter how bloated and corrupt the corporate behemoth becomes, the competitions themselves always throw up myriad grace notes of human quality.
Just to give examples from Tokyo last time out: how about the women’s park skateboarding, featuring eight finalists with an average age of seventeen? They rooted fiercely for each other, cheering and high-fiving each time one of them pulled off a successful move. When the favourite, Misugu Okamoto, fell on her last run and missed out on a medal, the others rushed to her and lifted her onto their shoulders.
Or perhaps the decathlon, when Australia’s Cedric Dubler was ranked stone-last after nine events but stayed in the competition because his great mate Ash Moloney had a shot at bronze. The last event was the 1500, and for the first 1400 metres Dubler paced Moloney beautifully, working out how fast they needed to go for Moloney to hang on to that bronze: then he stepped aside and roared Moloney on as only a pumped-up Aussie could.
And of course the high jump final, where the Qatari Mutaz Essa Barshim and Gianmarco Tamberi of Italy jumped each other to a standstill over the course of two hours. Facing the prospect of a jump-off that would have started lower than the height already cleared, they decided to share the gold medal. It was unplanned, spontaneous and beautifully resonant for atomised times: an honouring of each other and the competition, a prize doubled rather than halved.
The value of such generosity of spirit was already understood by the organisers of the 1924 Games. On the obverse of the André Rivaud-designed medals were two athletes, the winner taking the hand of the man he had beaten and helping him to his feet. Friendships form at these contests that endure for life. Jesse Owens and his German long jump rival Luz Long famously defied Hitler to become close both at the 1936 Berlin Olympics and afterwards too. Less well-known is that Harold Abrahams and Arthur Porritt, gold and bronze medallists respectively in the 1924 100m, dined together every year after that at 7pm on 7 July, the exact time and date of their final, and continued to do so until Abrahams’ death in 1978.
The range of disciplines is also part of the appeal. For a few days, millions round the world are gripped by a sport they haven’t even thought about since, well, four years before. For the majority of Olympic participants – who are neither millionaires nor superstars and household names only in their own homes – the quadrennial spotlight marks the apex of all their hopes and fears, something perfectly summed up by Molly Seidel, who won bronze in the Tokyo marathon having worked two jobs to fund herself. “I wanted to go and be that person who, when you’re racing, they’re all saying ‘Who the hell is this girl?’ I just wanted to stick my nose in where it didn’t belong and get after it. The Olympics only happens every four years: you might as well take your shot. I did get a bit overcome and start crying a little bit. This is the day you dream of your entire life. This is what it means to be an athlete.” This is also what it means to be an Olympian, to dream of being an Olympian, and to watch and marvel at those who’ve made it.
Does any of it make any difference? In macro terms, probably not. The IOC and UN have between them revived the ancient Olympic Truce for both Summer and Winter Games, running it from a week before the start of the Olympics to a week after the end of the Paralympics. Unsurprisingly, this has worked better in theory than practice, with the appropriate UN resolutions being as effective as UN resolutions tend to be.
No surprise as to the main culprit’s identity, either. With the 2008 war in Georgia, the 2014 annexation of Crimea and the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin has managed the kind of hat trick de Coubertin could hardly have envisaged and of which he would have emphatically disapproved. (Ironically, the IOC’s decision to allow competitors from Russia and Belarus to compete as Individual Neutral Athletes in 2024, without flags, anthems or national colours, is much nearer de Coubertin’s vision of man against man than the nationalistic jamboree the Games have become.)
Even high-profile political gestures at various tournaments have tended to mask more prosaic realities. Long was killed during the Allied invasion of Sicily in 1943 and Owens ended up racing horses for money back home. Tommie Smith and John Carlos’ Black Power salute on the Mexico City podium in 1968 is perhaps the most iconic sports image in history, but neither man thinks their battle is close to being won even today. “Have things changed in 50 years?” asks Smith. “Not as much as I hoped they would. And the people to fight those negatives are fewer because black folks don’t have that leadership, black or white, like Dr King or the Kennedys.” Carlos agrees, though more trenchantly as is his wont. “Donald Trump called young black men sons of bitches for kneeling. Sons of bitches! He said they weren’t respecting the military. What did he ever do in the military? What did any of his children do in the military? And then you’ve got police officers out there shooting young black men, and nobody is prosecuted. Nobody is sent to jail. It’s the same bullshit today that it was 50 years ago.”
But lack of change does not negate the efforts made in trying to secure that change. And in micro terms the Olympics do make a huge difference. For British rower Helen Glover, Paris 2024 will be her fourth Olympics and her second as a mother. Part of her motivation in committing to Tokyo 2020 with three infant children had been to show those children that it was possible to do even the hardest things. The other part had come unexpectedly, with scores of mothers telling her how she’d inspired them to get out and do things they’d let slip in the fog of family life. It wasn’t always exercise they’d gone back to, and it certainly wasn’t Olympic-level exercise: just a small reclamation of self, an identity other than the one revolving around their children.
A world without any of the good things the Olympics represent would be awful
A world without the Games as they are now is imaginable, in some ways even desirable: but a world without any of the good things the Olympics represent would be awful. We may as well seek a world without art or music or literature. Long after the brief flashes of triumph have faded and the medallists’ names are forgotten, the moments that endure are the moments of simple humanity, beyond which there is nothing at all.
And these moments bring home the essential truth that the sweep of history is always a mosaic, and what that mosaic looks like from afar is very different to its appearance close up. History is sometimes the mode of its dataset, rarely the median and the mean, and almost never the range: we seek narratives that skew, warp or exclude, the better to make us feel the way we want to feel. History is transition: it is lulls and storms, it is Friday nights and Monday mornings. Would the Roaring Twenties and the Olympics be classified as Friday nights or Monday mornings? It depends on who you ask.
Everyone remembers The Great Gatsby’s last line: “So we beat on boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.” But it’s the line before that which is the real kicker, the one that so perfectly nails the ever-present lacuna between the stories we tell ourselves and the reality beneath those stories. “Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgiastic future that year by year recedes before us. It eluded us then, but that’s no matter – tomorrow we will run faster, stretch out our arms farther. And then one fine morning…”
On one of the last mornings of his life, fine or otherwise, Long wrote to Owens from his army camp in Italy. He asked Owens to contact his son Kai-Heinrich after the war and tell him about their friendship. “Tell him” Long wrote, “how things can be between men on this earth.”
How things can be, indeed, and very much how we need to keep imagining them to be: but sadly, depressingly, not how things usually are.
Boris Starling is an award-winning author, screenwriter and journalist. He created the “Messiah” series which ran for five seasons on BBC1





